top of page

Groundwater banking—an investment in water security?

5 minutes ago
10 min read
Irrigated cotton in northern Australia (Credit: A. Salus)
Irrigated cotton in northern Australia (Credit: A. Salus)

On the surface, a bank account seems pretty simple. You probably have one and don’t even think about how it works. You put money in, and it sits there until you’re ready to withdraw it.


But what if you tried opening a bank account where you deposited and withdrew water instead of cash? In theory, it still seems straightforward—when water is plentiful, store it underground like a cash deposit, and when water is scarce, take it back out like a withdrawal.


But beneath that simple idea is something often controversial. Unlike your financial bank account, it’s not always clear who owns water, what it’s worth, or if it’ll even stay where you put it.


But in an era of droughts, climate variability, declining reservoir reliability, and growing demand from cities, agriculture, and industry (including data centers), more people and places are turning to groundwater. But groundwater is easily overused, and in some cases difficult, if not impossible, to replenish naturally on human timeframes.


In response, groundwater banking has gained attention as a way to make groundwater part of a sustainable water security strategy.


With today’s engineering and technology, building a groundwater bank is not necessarily challenging. Agreeing on and implementing rules and regulations that determine ownership, equity, and environmental impacts is considerably harder—particularly for a resource we can’t see and that most believe should be a common public good.


Who truly owns banked water? Who should benefit from it? Who should own any risk? Is it sensible for water managers to act like investors, and is it even reasonable to treat water like we treat money? Why would we even want to bank water? These are the questions FLUSH explores in this article.


What is groundwater banking?

At its simplest, groundwater banking intentionally stores water underground and creates an accounting system that lets you recover the same amount later. That intentional storing is the ‘deposit,’ and recovering the water later is the ‘withdrawal.’ That’s where the banking metaphor comes in. Theoretically, you can withdraw only the amount of water deposited.


In a groundwater bank, a deposit is counted when groundwater is intentionally recharged into the aquifer from other sources (e.g., rivers, reservoirs, overland flood flows, recycled or imported water), or alternatively, when existing water is left in place, and another source is used instead (e.g., surface water).

Tonopah Desert Recharge Project in Arizona (Credit: Arizona Daily Star)
Tonopah Desert Recharge Project in Arizona (Credit: Arizona Daily Star)

Groundwater banking differs from pure aquifer recharge because it assumes that some of the stored water will be recovered in the future. That is our guiding light as we navigate terms sometimes used interchangeably, such as managed aquifer recharge (MAR) or aquifer storage and recovery (ASR).


Therefore, to have a working bank, we must be able to recover our deposits. We need technical methods for withdrawing water, but also clear regulations on how that process works and a framework for tracking who has made deposits and withdrawals, as well as each individual’s account balance.


Some water banks include water market-like features, such as the Kern Water Bank in California. The water bank manager—the Kern Water Bank Authority (KWBA)—gives credits to those who deposit water into the groundwater bank, identifying their right to extract the water later. The KWBA then allows people to sell or trade their credits to others within a specified management area.


Why groundwater banking can seem like an attractive water management (and investment) strategy

Smoothing out supply variability

From a water management perspective, the appeal of groundwater banking is relatively straightforward. Where water needs increasingly don’t align with water availability, groundwater banking can provide a ‘savings account’ or drought reserve to help balance out these fluctuations and increase overall reliability of a water supply system.

Infrastructure at SAWS H2Oaks Center in San Antonio, TX (Credit: Texas Water Newsroom)
Infrastructure at SAWS H2Oaks Center in San Antonio, TX (Credit: Texas Water Newsroom)

The San Antonio Water System (SAWS), the public water utility owned by the City of San Antonio, in Texas, exemplifies how a city’s use of groundwater banking can maximize its water allocation and reduce local water risk long-term. During wet years, SAWS extracts excess water from its Edwards Aquifer entitlement and banks the water in a nearby aquifer with suitable hydrologic conditions. During dry periods, SAWS retrieves banked water, as needed, to prevent over-pumping of the Edwards Aquifer and maintain a consistent water supply for the City of San Antonio.


The benefits of banking underground

Underground storage may appeal to water managers where hydrologic and subsurface conditions allow. These are areas with ample storage volume and rock formations that allow easy (and affordable) water transfer. It may also appeal in scenarios with seasonal excess water (such as during rainy seasons) or water from other sources, such as the SAWS. It can also be appealing in places where groundwater governance systems are already in place.


Groundwater banks use natural or existing structures, reducing environmental impacts and the infrastructure needed for new dams and massive concrete structures, while limiting impacts on both terrestrial and aquatic creatures. Infrastructure to deposit and withdraw water, such as percolation ponds and injection/extraction wells, still needs to be built and requires space, but is generally less intensive and invasive.


In addition, a groundwater bank is a reservoir with a roof. Water underground is largely protected from evaporation, which matters most in hot, dry places. In Namibia, the vast majority of rainfall is lost to evaporation before any humans can use it. So rather than build a new surface reservoir, the capital, Windhoek, started recharging the large aquifer beneath the city with excess water from rainfall and treated wastewater.

View of City of Windhoek, Namibia and extent of Windhoek aquifer (Credit: Republic of Namibia Ministry of Industries Mines and Energy)
View of City of Windhoek, Namibia and extent of Windhoek aquifer (Credit: Republic of Namibia Ministry of Industries Mines and Energy)

Energy use and costs of groundwater banking depend on the site, but underground storage, generally, sits in the middle of the spectrum. Operationally, it can be more energy-intensive than a reservoir but less so than surface water or desalination, which may require significant treatment. Depending on the size of the initiative, upfront infrastructure costs can be much lower than for a large dam or advanced water treatment plant. 


The attraction for investors

We can treat a groundwater bank as a ‘savings account’ with water available to draw on for use in the future, or as an investment to sell when the time is right. Either way, you give up water availability now in exchange for having it when it's scarce. It’s scarce when it becomes most valuable. As shortages become more prevalent, this value matters to both water managers and investors, but in different ways. For water managers, banked water is a drought or scarcity reserve to supply cities, agriculture, and the environment. For investors, banked water is a hedge and an opportunity to see monetary returns on a high-value asset.


Investors are already showing interest in water. In California, water now trades as a futures contract on the stock exchange. Pension funds and universities have bought farmland for its water rights. In Arizona, investment firms have purchased rural land hoping to sell the water to growing cities, though legislation to enable this has not been approved.

Seeing the opportunity, some private entities have become interested in setting up their own water banks. The potential implications of this are discussed later.


Where the finance analogy breaks down

Analogizing an aquifer to a bank account helps conceptualize the abstract idea of storing water. However, there is a risk of viewing aquifers too much like bank accounts.

Money in a bank is discrete and measurable– a dollar goes in, and that dollar is available when you need it.


Water in an aquifer isn’t quite like that dollar in a bank account. Instead, that dollar–or, more appropriately, unit of water–goes into a shared natural system. Depending on the aquifer, that unit of water mixes with the water already there. It might alter the existing water quality, impact the surrounding ecosystem, or flow into new areas no longer accessible to the depositor.


When you deposit or withdraw from the bank, it impacts only you, but those actions in a groundwater bank could affect future quality and accessibility for you and others.

Groundwater banks also have different goals from financial institutions. They have to balance broader objectives around economic, environmental, and public interests. A much messier, and more human, set of goals.


This is where the hard questions come in…


Who owns banked groundwater?

Theoretically, banked groundwater is owned by the person or entity who puts that water into the ground. If you own water and put it into a groundwater bank, you have the right to withdraw it later.


Clear water rights ownership is fundamental to enabling sustainable water management, and this is true with groundwater banking. The local government or water authority is responsible for establishing ownership, quantity and usage limits, and extraction locations. Seems simple, but even deeply regulated countries like the US often lack clear ownership and rules around groundwater, which can lead to overextraction.


Like any bank, a groundwater bank also needs clear monitoring (water metering) and detailed accounting to track what water is put in and taken out, avoiding overdrafts.


Just as a bank account may have fees attached, governance and regulation may impose a ‘fee’ on water deposits. This ‘fee’ (or tax) helps replenish overused aquifers over the long term. In Arizona, for example, water owners obtain long-term storage credits for the amount of water they recharged, minus a 5% cut left for the aquifer.


Does the water you own stay where it’s put?

A common question, and the answer is…it depends. Some aquifers connect across large areas underground, allowing lots of movement, while others are isolated and confined.

That is why, beyond clear governance and accounting, detailed aquifer characterization is essential before establishing a groundwater bank. Water managers and users alike need to understand how water moves in their region to determine whether groundwater banking is feasible and, if so, where water can be recharged and recovered without harming other users or the environment.

An infographic on what an aquifer actually is and how groundwater is stored and moves (Credit: American Geosciences Institute)
An infographic on what an aquifer actually is and how groundwater is stored and moves (Credit: American Geosciences Institute)

Arizona shows what happens when recovery is an afterthought. The internationally recognized Arizona Water Banking Authority (AWBA) has been banking its excess Colorado River allocation for over 30 years. The state’s aquifers are very suitable for storage and have allowed Arizona to bank around 4.4 million acre-feet of water—nearly the same total capacity as Lake Shasta, California’s largest reservoir. Putting water in was the easy part. Now it's time to use banked water, and plans are still underway for how to recover it. 


Arizona state law allows extraction in a different location from recharge. While this sounds flexible and useful for water users, it challenges water managers and makes monitoring difficult. A mismatch between deposit and withdrawal locations could cause potentially long-term issues.


Speaking of…


Can we avoid harming others when banking groundwater?

Theoretically, good planning can prevent any negative consequences of groundwater banking for both people and the environment. But what if we don’t have all the information? Who bears the risk of poor management?


Hydrogeologists and engineers can characterize, model, and plan…but risks remain. Water recovery may still lower groundwater levels, drying up shallower wells. It might pull contaminants into new areas, cause land subsidence, or starve groundwater-dependent ecosystems. Recharge also carries risks, such as introducing contaminants or flooding land above shallow aquifers.


These are potentially significant consequences, though many can occur with any poorly managed groundwater use, whether or not groundwater banking occurs.


Conversely, when done well, groundwater banking can deliver environmental and social benefits, such as percolation ponds becoming environmental corridors and groundwater recharge replenishing aquifers, improving groundwater-dependent ecosystems, and stabilizing agricultural communities.

Restored perennial and season marsh and riparian forest at Wildlands Mitigation Bank in California (Credit: EPA)
Restored perennial and season marsh and riparian forest at Wildlands Mitigation Bank in California (Credit: EPA)

California provides an example of how to protect against undesired impacts and continued overdrafting. In California’s 2014 Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA), the state sets out protections against negative third-party impacts from groundwater banking and requires mitigation measures where impacts can’t be avoided. The Kern Water Bank has a mitigation fund to address impacts due to its groundwater banking activities.


But are these actions enough? Proponents and critics remain divided on this issue. What is clear, however, is the need for strong governance and ongoing dialogue among all stakeholders to achieve equitable outcomes.


Is there a market for private groundwater banks?

Many groundwater banks are run by government or partially government-owned entities focused on improving water resilience for their customers or communities. This includes most of the groundwater banks we’ve discussed so far. But as water becomes a more valuable commodity, more private entities are interested in its potential profits.


We must distinguish, though, between a private bank developed to support a specific purpose (like local agriculture) and one developed purely to sell water to the highest bidder.


California’s Kern Water Bank shows how blurry the line can be. The state initially developed the water bank and then transferred it to private entities dominated by agricultural interests. Supporters point out that users fund and maintain their own system, which supports the local economy—a system the state struggled to execute. Critics say the move buoyed the fortunes of large agricultural entities (not all locally owned), prioritizing profit over the public good.

Farming and irrigation in the San Joaquin Valley, one of California’s major agricultural producers. Parts of the San Joaquin Valley use the Kern Water Bank. (Credit: Public Policy Institute of California)
Farming and irrigation in the San Joaquin Valley, one of California’s major agricultural producers. Parts of the San Joaquin Valley use the Kern Water Bank. (Credit: Public Policy Institute of California)

In another example from the 1980s, viticulturalists in Langhorne Creek, South Australia implemented groundwater banking to combat water shortages impacting their livelihoods. While developed as a banking scheme to support the local economy, at its peak the initiative was using water at four times the rate of recharge—more a groundwater mining operation than a sustainable bank.


Environmental groups and state agencies have challenged the proposed Mojave Groundwater Bank for years for the same reason: the recharge plans are grossly out of line with withdrawal. The Mojave initiative differs from the two above in its intent to become purely a business for selling water—most of which could be sent out of the region.

Similarly, the Washington State government shut down a proposed private surface water bank for fear that a private company would control and profit from a scarce public resource while local communities struggled to meet their own water needs.


As water grows scarcer and more valuable, private capital is looking for ways in, and a groundwater bank is an obvious vehicle. But few markets are as politically charged. To investors, banked water is an asset to be traded. To communities, water is a necessity and profiting from storing it feels like a line crossed.


So, should water be managed like any other tangible resource?

Likening a groundwater bank to a financial bank can be a useful metaphor. But we can’t ignore the fact that aquifers are not bank accounts. They don’t offer clear ownership, tidy accounting, or a guaranteed return of the original deposit.


Here, we also have a moral dilemma. Financial banks don't offer those freely either. They come from rules, regulations, and risk frameworks built around a purpose: covering costs and earning profit. We have seen that governments can struggle to implement and manage groundwater banks, but that private investment control, while effective under the right circumstances, can draw community ire and call into question the equitable management of water.


Groundwater banking can be a useful water management strategy in the right context. Governments and water managers might borrow from the investor’s toolkit and consider risk management, optionality, diversification, strategic reserves, and an honest look at the costs of saving water now versus the costs of not having it later. These costs are not just financial; they also include environmental and social costs.


At the same time, there may be an opportunity for private money to help build, run, and maintain banks. But it only works if recovering the water gets as much attention as storing it, and if governance and purpose get as much attention as hydrogeology.

bottom of page